Q1 to Q19 [Q&A Summary] 第2回/天空の狭間・雲海についてのご質問(再投稿)
Among the questions we have received recently, there were many parts that overlapped with content posted before, so I will guide you to this article once again. I hope it will be helpful as a reference.
【Q&A Summary】 Part 2 / Questions about the Sky Between Heaven and Clouds
Some parts may overlap with the first edition, please forgive me.
This time, we have organized a lot of the questions we received into a Q&A format.
Rather than just giving answers, we delve into background, approaches, and actual experiences, so I would be glad if you read it as a narrative.
Please take a look at the questions summarized in the first edition here.
Sky Between Heaven and Gates Q&A 1st edition
We have summarized the questions received so far.
⸻
Q1. How long does it take to get used to it?
•
•
In the first month, simply verifying on the chart by placing arrows without trading is effective.
As you get accustomed, you will naturally make judgments like “aim when there is movement, but always place SL at break-even”.
I myself am not a “master = finished” but continually thinking about daily updates.
That’s why I feel learning is not a one-time thing but something to be continually accumulated.
Q2. Does it work for prop trading or full-time traders?
• Prop trading environments have high commissions,
• Therefore, it’s more stable to prioritize “sky zone target with risk-reward focus.”
I am not a full-time trader but a part-time trader who runs a shop personally.
So I can’t say definitively whether you can do it full-time, but by using an EA filter to limit entries and ensuring you can switch to monitoring immediately after entry, I believe there is enough possibility.
⸻
Q3. What are the specifications of the Cloud Sea indicator?
• Signals occur when strong movement continues
• Signals do not appear during rapid price moves
• Therefore there is a risk of getting in at a high or low price
I once experienced a large loss with a “totally hands-off EA.”
Q4. What is the difference between Sky Between Heaven and Gates and Cloud Sea?
• Sky Between Heaven and Gates →
• Cloud Sea →
Cloud Sea only proves its value when used in combination with Sky Between Heaven and Gates.
Q5. Which currency pairs can be used?
• Sky Between Heaven and Gates:
• Cloud Sea: Originally for 1-minute XAUUSD (GOLD), but also works well with USDJPY, EURUSD, BTCUSD, etc.
However, regardless of domestic or international accounts,
⸻
Q6. Can it be used in environments with wide spreads?
If you combine EA filters (ADX/ATR/SMA) and trailing, you can absorb spread impact to some extent, so adjust according to your environment.
Q7. About EA stop loss and take profit settings
•
• ATR multiplier can be adjusted according to market. If ATR20 = 20 pips, multiplier 2.0 → trailing width 40 pips.
• EA works for both demo and real accounts. Account authentication can be switched any number of times.
• Multiple exit features (fixed stop, ATR trail, high/low trail, built-in shift) are built-in.
Therefore, risk is limited while aiming to take bigger profits when possible.
Q8. Can EA operate completely automatically?
• If you leave exit decisions to the EA, win rate increases but risk-reward decreases
• If you incorporate discretionary exits for returns, results become more stable
⸻
Q9. How much trading time is required?
• Only during London time
• Only in the morning or only at night
• If one trade can yield a big gain, stop there
Also, at the suggestion of buyers, we introduced filters for SMA, ATR, ADX, price range, and spreads.
This reduces the number of trades but makes the operation more stable.
⸻
Q10. Can I get numbers like “monthly return 〇〇%” or “requires ×× million in margin”?
Q11. How do you manage funds yourself?
Q12. What market conditions are Sky Between Heaven and Gates strong in?
Q13. How do you respond when busy?
Q13. How do you decide on stops?
• High/low of the previous bar
• Median of the entry line
• Exit with a pre-determined fixed pips
• Use the opposite entry line as insurance
Q13. How are the verification articles created?
Q14. Do you have information that’s helpful about monthly profit?
Q15. Could you share actual buyer feedback?
Q16. Does it suit traders who already have rules?
This has become quite voluminous, but I hope repeated reading will help you develop your own pattern.
Q17. Are EA entries and manual entries the same?
Q18. What added filters are included?
• Spread filter
• Price-range filter
• ADX / ATR filter
• SMA filter
⸻
Q19. Are there recommended values for the filter numbers?
E-book, Introduction to Sky Between Heaven
EA-triggered breakout strategy
“Sky Between Heaven” is a simple strategy where you delegate entry to an automatic entry EA, and the trader focuses on monitoring after entry and executing exit rules.
ADX, ATR, SMA and other filters are also included.
The main Sky Between Heaven page
Cloud Sea UNKAI here
Why publish negative results?
In Investment Navi+, we deliberately publish negative results without hiding them.The reason is that “trading cannot always win.”
Rather, by recording losses, we can analyze in what situations we lose and make the logic more robust.
Instead of obsessing over each win or loss,
1 week to 1 month span,the total balance being positiveis what matters most
• “Happy because I won today.”
• “Worried because I lost today.”
“Want to win”
Stability gained by sticking to the rules
•
•
This reduces human intervention and eliminates indecision.
⸻
There are countless techniques in technical analysis, such as moving averages, RSI, MACD, stochastic, Parabolic SAR, ADX, ATR, CCI, trendlines and channels, Fibonacci retracements and extensions, Ichimoku, volume, as well as support/resistance lines...
There is no single correct method,
⸻
We verify Sky Between Heaven and Gates with the “maximum profit exit” rule,
What matters in trading is not “win rate” but “reproducibility”
Many traders worry about win rate, but
•
⸻
Strategy to aim for overall profit
If you are interested in Sky Between Heaven and Gates or Cloud Sea, you are invited to join the online community
Join the online community here
Within the online community, detailed trading logic cannot be explained, but you can join the “chart critique community” that utilizes Sky Between Heaven and Gates.
To those interested in Sky Between Heaven,
Build a foundation to make rule-based judgments without hesitation in short-term trading──
That is the basic philosophy of Sky Between Heaven.
Free materials here:
▶︎ Download ‘Tracks to the Gap’
In ‘Tracks to the Gap,’ we explain more clearly the criteria for determining when trades can be made.
It also explains in diagrams and case-by-case explanations the entry points and zone selection that could not be fully conveyed on the Sky Between Heaven page.
Even beginners will find it easy to reproduce, so if you are curious, please also use this.
If you are interested, please first receive the free material ‘Tracks to the Gap’.
From there, your first step in the Sky Between Heaven will begin.
“Shall I include this chart?”
When you hesitate, I hope this helps shift your thinking from “feeling” to “judgment based on rules.”