[Read and Learn Realistic Investment Course in 3 Minutes • Lesson 16: A performance with a drawdown can look higher in win rate]
Today's Conclusion
The win rate is calculated only from the trades that were closed. If you keep a losing trade open, that loss does not appear on the performance table.
Even with a method that has a 50% win rate, if you carry over 9 losses out of 10, the win rate on the performance table will exceed 90%.
01 —The denominator of win rate is the number of closes
Win rate = number of wins ÷ number of closes. Positions that are still held do not enter the numerator or the denominator.
Suppose in Lecture 6 you enter 20 times with a method that has 50% win rate and RR 1:2, and in reality you had 10 wins and 10 losses. If you don’t cut some losses and hold them as unrealized losses, the performance table changes as follows.
※The method itself has not changed. What changed is whether losses were closed or not.
By carrying over losses for 9 trades, a 50% win-rate method becomes “win-rate over 90%.” If you had cut losses, the losses of 10,000 yen each over 9 times would have reduced by 90,000 yen and disappeared from the table.
02 —Waiting turns losses can turn into small wins
Continuing to hold unrealized losses means some will eventually revert toward the breakeven point. If you close those at that point, trades that would have been losses become small wins recorded as profits.
Of the 9 cases above, 6 returned to break-even and could be closed for +1,000 yen each. The remaining 3 did not revert, their loss locations were exceeded significantly, resulting in a total unrealized loss of 1,200,000 yen. Here are such scenarios.
If you only look at the performance table, the carried-over side has higher win rate and profit. If you close everything, the ranking would flip.
Moreover, the ones that returned to a win are just +1,000 yen small wins. The ones that did not revert have expanded by several times their losses. This is the same as performing Lecture 8’s “sunk costs and profit taking” without taking profit or loss.
03 — unrealized losses do not appear in the balance
A trading account has two numbers: balance and usable funds (effective margin). Balance is the total of closed P/L. Usable funds are balance plus current unrealized P/L.
If the performance chart shows only balance, no matter how large your unrealized losses, the line will still rise to the right. The gap between the two lines grows when there are unclosed losses piling up.
In swing trading, it is normal to have positions not yet closed. What you should check is whether unrealized losses exceeding the stop-loss level remain for weeks. Recalculating win rate with those included brings you closer to the true figure.
Truly close-to-accurate win rate
=wins ÷ (wins + losses + unrealized losses)
Today's Check
In the performance table you’re concerned about, look for a column labeled “usable funds” or “unsettled positions.”
If found, add the unrealized positions to the number of losses and recalculate the win rate. If you have 18 wins, 2 losses, and 6 unrealized positions, then 18 ÷ (18 + 2 + 6) ≈ 69%. That is quite different from 90% on the table.
▶Next Episode
Next time: “Why do averaging-down and martingale curves look like they rise to the right?.” By adding to unrealized losses to lower the average price, even small rebounds can be closed as wins. We will calculate what else you end up carrying.
※This article is intended to provide information for investment decision-making and does not advocate buying or selling any specific financial product. The figures in the article are for explanation and do not guarantee future results. With margin trading such as FX and CFDs, there is a risk of losses exceeding the principal. Please make investment decisions at your own risk.