To people who take profits immediately with GOLD|Three reasons profits don’t grow and how to decide
There are unrealized profits.
“Before they vanish,” I close the position immediately.
After that, the price moves decisively in the direction I anticipated.
On the other hand, when there are unrealized losses, I wait for a rebound, thinking it should recover.
Even though the number of winning trades is high, the account hasn’t grown as much as I expected.
If you trade GOLD with discretion, you may have months like this.
I’ll start with the conclusion first.
Profits are taken early not because you are cowardly.
It’s because you haven’t decided where to exit before you enter.
In this article, I will整理 three reasons why profits become early.
Then I will introduce three ways to decide to extend profits.
You’re not the only one who can’t hold onto profits
I also suffered losses from information products and high-risk martingale EAs.
I learned that executing without emotion costs more than I expected.
So I began creating an execution method that excludes emotion for myself.
This article is the整理 of that process.
Three reasons profits become early
① The pain of unrealized gains is larger than you think
People feel the pain of loss more strongly than the joy of gain.
This is the psychology called “loss aversion” in behavioral economics.
Even a small decrease in unrealized gains makes you feel “I’m losing.”
To avoid that pain, you choose small but certain profits.
The psychology is the opposite of delaying a stop loss; in take profit, it tends to work the other way.
As a result, profits stay small and losses tend to become larger.
② You evaluate yourself by the number of wins
A high win rate feels reassuring.
Therefore, if there is any small profit, you want to close the position to increase your “one win.”
But growing the account isn’t by number of wins.
It’s by how much a single win outweighs a single loss.
③ You decide why you exit based on your current mood
If you don’t have exit conditions written before you enter, decisions start by watching the screen.
With every small push, you hesitate, thinking, “is this the end?”
The longer you stare at the screen, the more reasons you find to exit.
Three ways to extend profits
① Write exit conditions in price before entering
Before entry, write in one line the condition to exit when profit is realized.
The trick is to decide by price, for example “exit if it breaks the recent low.”
Until the condition is met, don’t exit based on mood.
② Record not win rate, but the size of wins and losses
In the records, write not only the number of wins and losses, but the size of each trade.
Compare the average win and average loss once a month.
Even if the win rate drops, as long as wins are larger than losses, it’s fine.
If your scoring criteria change, you’ll have fewer reasons to exit early.
③ Move the exit position from the back as the price advances
As price advances, move the exit position backward accordingly. This is called a trailing stop.
There are methods to take partial profits and trail the rest. The important thing is to decide the direction and timing in advance.
Reference material: In the Gold Canon case
I’ll show an example of “trailing the exit position from behind.” This is our Gold Canon.
In short, it’s “turn a non-changing GOLD signal into semi-automatic with one button.”
Set for XAUUSD in MT5 with 5-minute chart signals and a buyer bonus EA.
- An engine that only enters when the timeframe direction aligns, with two buys and one sell
- Closings use trailing stop to extend profits
- Stop loss and trailing stop are placed on the broker’s side
- No new entries on Fridays. All positions closed before NY close
- Arrows are non-repaint. You can choose days to rely on RUN ON/OFF
The exit position updates according to the rules by the EA.
There is no moment of doubt while watching the screen, thinking “this might be the end.”
However, on Fridays all positions are closed before NY close.
Even in the middle of a larger trend, it’s designed not to carry over into the weekend.
Numbers: prioritize bad results first
We tested from 2019 to October 2026 on our MT5.
With each engine set to 1% risk, PF is 1.95 and maximum DD is 12.0%.
In 2019, it was almost a flat year.
The win rate is 49.1% per basket.
We designed it so losses are small and wins are extended.
Even in 2024–2026, which were not used for rule decisions, PF was 2.75.
This is also a backtest result.
Note: All are backtests (simulations).
In actual trading, results vary due to order rejections and spread widening.
Answering common questions in advance
Q. Do signals disappear or move later?
A. They are no-repaint signals that display a confirmed signal. Past arrows were signals at the time.
Q. How much capital is required?
A. With 0.01 lots and the standard setup of 3 engines, recommended funds are 2 million yen or more.
The maximum drawdown under the same conditions was about 700,000 yen.
If using TRI and SELL, recommended funds are 1,000,000 yen or more.
※Reference value for 0.01 lots: backtest from Jan 2025 to Oct 2026, 1 USD = 158 JPY, including spread and costs. If needed, consider using an account type with smaller contract sizes
Q. Is martingale (averaging down) dangerous?
A. With a buying engine, add an identical lot up to a maximum of two times.
With 0.01 lots, the maximum lot per basket is 0.03.
Stop loss is placed on the broker’s side.
A. If you turn RUN OFF, no new orders will be placed.
You decide the moment to stop, such as before an indicator release or on busy days.
Q. Can I test it with my broker?
A. There is a 3-day free trial (signal indicator).
With your own MT5, you can check how the arrows appear.
In 3 days, new signals may not appear.
The EA is available as a buyer bonus for hedge accounts in the product version.
Who it’s not suited for
- Someone seeking a tool that guarantees you will never lose
- Someone who wants to use large lots without preparing recommended funds
- Someone who prioritizes high win rate above all
For those who want to keep discretion and make split-position exits or move price targets easier.
There is also the MT5 panel “Trade Pilot Pro.”
https://www.gogojungle.co.jp/tools/indicators/85576
Summary
The three reasons profits become early were:
- The pain of unrealized gains is larger than you think
- You evaluate yourself by the number of wins
- You decide why to exit based on the mood at the moment
What you decide is to write the exit condition in price before entering.
Record not the win rate, but the size of wins and losses.
And move the exit position by trailing from the back.
Finally: Why I created this tool
What I wanted was not a tool to boast about high win rates.
A signal that doesn’t change afterward and execution without emotion.
And rules that let you wait without hesitation even when profits are being made.
I couldn’t find it, so I made it for myself. That is Gold Canon.
I don’t intend to cut only the good results.
First, for 3 days, please check on your own chart before deciding.
▶ 3-day free trial:https://www.gogojungle.co.jp/tools/indicators/84465
Past performance does not guarantee future profits. Please make investment decisions at your own risk.