This is Shiro!

ABUATR2 and FUTUREBAND2 seem somewhat similar

Which settlement should I use?

The settlements for ABUATR2 and FUTUREBAND2 have similar stop-loss and take-profit points, so there are users who are unsure which one to use.

In this article,

Which is better, ABUATR2 or FUTUREBAND2?

We tested this using Prime Combo Signal data.

Differences and Characteristics of ABUATR2 and FUTUREBAND2

Basically, they feel similar regarding settlement locations.

However, when viewed overall,ABUATR2 seems to have slightly tighter SLas I feel.

As a result,

the win rate varies depending on the filter

which is a somewhat unsatisfying answer.

For example,

• Current Histogram DX2 upper part only
• Current ADXDX

In that case, FUTUREBAND2 settlements yield a higher win rate (with 50,000 candles).

Dollar/Yen 1-hour chart

Left ABUATR 2, Right Band 2

• Current ABUDMI
• One higher time frame ADXDX

If you use a higher time frame filter (MTF), ABUATR2 has a higher win rate.

Dollar/Yen 15-minute chart

Left ABUATR2, Right Band 2

Perhaps the results vary with different filter combinations.

In all cases, the win rate differences were within 2–3% error.

【Evidence & Data Verification】ABUATR2 vs FUTUREBAND2: Which settlement should you use?

I think this is a matter of preference.

Let me share my personal viewpoint.

I lean toward ABUATR2, especially for stop-loss.

In particular, ABUATR2's stop-loss aligns well with the original ATR stop-loss, making it logical and easy to use.

Regarding FUTUREBAND2 settlements,they visualize the width between the zenith and nadir pointsin a way.

From market observation, in 28 currencies,

there is a tendency to move within a two-point range

that is the nature.

there are patterns where the price does not rebound from the line, but after reaching a point for long or short, it continues and then buys on a dip or sells on a rebound.

If you set Band Touch 2 at that time, you end up getting caught at the dip-buy or rebound-sell, and it tends to hit you more on the stop-loss than ABUATR2.

Therefore, I think ABUATR2 has the upper hand in terms of stop-loss.

That concludes this article.